Exclusive: Netflix vs Amazon vs Sky’s Now TV on the IMDB Top 250 Movies

Netflix vs Amazon Video vs Sky's Now TV - our exclusive research shows which has the most films in the IMDB Top 250? And why is it the movie coverage of all the streaming services is so poor?

It’s official. Movie fans get a poor return from UK subscription streaming services such as Netflix, Amazon Video and Now TV.

Using the Internet Movie Database Top 250 as a barometer of popular films, Shopomo found that even if you subscribed to all 3 streaming networks simultaneously you would still be able to see fewer than half of the films on the IMDB leaderboard.

To be exact, between them Now TV, Netflix and Amazon Video served up 115 films from the IMDB Top 250 – just 46% of the total.

When you compare that to the sheer breadth of catalogue you get when you sign up for the big music services like Spotify or Apple Music, you can’t help but conclude that movie fans are being seriously short-changed.

Classic blockbusters that aren’t on any of the big 3 UK streaming services include Jaws, Pulp Fiction, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Back to the Future, Alien, and Blade Runner.

Classic blockbusters that aren’t on any of the big 3 streaming services include Jaws, Pulp Fiction, Raiders of the Lost Ark, Back to the Future

Now TV is the clear winner of the IMDB test, which reflects the service’s focus on recent blockbusters and popular classics – and its deals with all the major Hollywood studios.

It ‘scored’ 70 out of the top 250 movies, or a 28% strike rate, which was twice as much as the second placed Netflix on 12%. Amazon Video trailed the group with a measly 15 films from the top 250 in its streaming catalogue (6%) – which is ironic as Amazon owns the IMDB. Oops.

The relatively low scores all round underlines just how far any of the three streaming services are from offering a comprehensive film library.

Foreign language, black and white and more intellectual movies on the IMDB top 250 are conspicuous by their absence – which may be understandable given the commercial objectives – but why no place at all for all-time movie classics like Citizen Kane, Seven Samurai and Pan’s Labyrinth?

Of course, it should be emphasised that any survey like this is only a snapshot of the streaming playing field at a particular moment (in this instance, the week commencing June 6, 2016).

Films appear and disappear from the listings with the depressing regularity of whack-a-moles as contracts start and expire, while there seems to be no rhyme or reason behind which films actually appear on which service: so Now TV has Jaws 2 but not the original Jaws, while Amazon has The Dark Knight but not The Dark Knight Rises or Batman Begins.

Movies are not the only content that these streaming services offer, and each of the Big 3 have spent heavily on exclusive, bespoke content to provide a unique selling proposition. But the results how far we are from having the best movies available on demand to stream from any or all of these subscription services.

See our in-depth Netflix vs Amazon Video vs Now TV smackdown feature.

The Results: Percentage of films on the IMDB Top 250

Netflix
12%
NowTV
28%
Amazon
6%

 

Netflix Now TV Amazon Video
The Shawshank Redemption Yes No No
The Godfather No Yes No
The Godfather Part II No Yes No
The Dark Knight No No Yes
Schindler’s List No No Yes
Pulp Fiction No No No
12 Angry Men Yes No No
The Lord of the Rings: Return of the King No Yes No
The Good, the Bad and the Ugly No Yes No
Fight Club No No No
The Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring No Yes No
Star Wars Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back No Yes No
Forrest Gump No Yes No
Inception No Yes No
The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers No Yes No
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest No Yes No
Goodfellas No Yes No
The Matrix No Yes No
Seven Samurai No No No
Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope No Yes No
City of God Yes No No
Se7en No No No
The Silence of the Lambs No Yes No
It’s a Wonderful Life No Yes No
The Usual Suspects No Yes No
Life Is Beautiful No No No
Léon: The Professional No No No
Once Upon a Time in the West No Yes No
Spirited Away No No No
Saving Private Ryan No Yes No
Interstellar No Yes No
Casablanca No No No
American History X No Yes No
Psycho No No No
City Lights No No No
Raiders of the Lost Ark No No No
The Intouchables No No No
Rear Window Yes No No
Modern Times No Yes No
The Green Mile No Yes No
Terminator 2: Judgment Day No No No
The Pianist No No Yes
The Departed No Yes No
Back to the Future No No No
Whiplash No Yes No
Gladiator No Yes No
Memento No Yes No
Apocalypse Now No No Yes
The Prestige No No No
The Lion King No Yes No
Dr. Strangelove or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb No No No
Sunset Boulevard No Yes No
Alien No No No
The Great Dictator No No No
The Lives of Others Yes No No
Cinema Paradiso Yes No No
Django Unchained Yes No No
The Shining No Yes No
Paths of Glory No No No
Grave of the Fireflies No No No
WALL-E No No No
The Dark Knight Rises No No No
American Beauty No Yes No
Aliens No No No
Princess Mononoke No No No
Oldboy No No No
Citizen Kane No No No
North by Northwest No No No
Once Upon a Time in America Yes No No
Das Boot No No No
Vertigo Yes No No
Star Wars: Episode VI – Return of the Jedi No Yes No
Witness for the Prosecution No No No
M No No No
Amélie No No Yes
Reservoir Dogs Yes No No
Braveheart No No No
Requiem for a Dream No No No
A Clockwork Orange No Yes Yes
Taxi Driver No No No
Double Indemnity No No No
Toy Story 3 No Yes Yes
Lawrence of Arabia No Yes No
Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind No No Yes
Full Metal Jacket No Yes No
Amadeus No Yes No
2001: A Space Odyssey No No No
Bicycle Thieves No No No
Singin’ in the Rain No No No
Snatch No No No
Toy Story No Yes Yes
Monty Python and the Holy Grail No No No
Inglourious Basterds No No No
The Kid No No No
L.A. Confidential No No No
For a Few Dollars More No Yes No
The Apartment Yes No No
Rashomon No No No
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade No No No
Scarface (1983) No Yes No
A Separation No No No
Metropolis No No No
All About Eve No No No
Children of Heaven No No No
Yojimbo No No No
The Treasure of the Sierra Madre No No No
Batman Begins No No No
The Hunt No No No
3 Idiots No No No
Children of Heaven Yes No No
Some Like It Hot No Yes No
Unforgiven No No No
Good Will Hunting Yes No No
The Third Man No No No
Raging Bull No No No
Downfall Yes No No
Inside Out No Yes No
Die Hard Yes No No
The Great Escape No No No
Chinatown No Yes No
Heat No No No
Room No No No
On The Waterfront No No No
Pan’s Labyrinth No No No
My Neighbor Totoro No No No
Ran No No No
Ikuru No No No
Captain America: Civil War No No No
Mr Smith Goes to Washington No Yes No
Bridge on the River Kwai No Yes No
The Gold Rush No No No
The Secret In Their Eyes No No No
Star Wars: The Force Awakens No No No
The Seventh Seal No No No
Blade Runner No No No
Sunrise No No No
Lock Stock and Two Smoking Barrels No No No
Howl’s Moving Castle No No No
Tokyo Story No No No
Casino No Yes No
The General No No No
Wild Strawberries No No No
The Elephant Man No No No
Warrior Yes No No
Wolf of Wall Street Yes No No
The Message No No No
A Beautiful Mind No Yes No
V For Vendetta No No No
Judgment at Nurenberg No No No
Gran Torino No No No
The Big Lebowski No No No
Incendies No No No
The Deer Hunter No No Yes
Rebecca No No No
Gone With The Wind No No No
Cool Hand Luke No Yes No
How to Train Your Dragon Yes No No
Zootopia No No No
The Sixth Sense No No No
Finding Nemo No No No
The Thing No Yes No
No Country For Old Men Yes Yes No
Into The Wild Yes No No
Mary and Max No No No
Gone Girl No Yes No
Kill Bill: Vol. 1 No Yes No
It Happened One Night No No No
Rush No No No
Life of Brian No No No
There Will Be Blood Yes No No
Hotel Rwanda No No No
Platoon No Yes No
The Maltese Falcon No No No
Mad Max: Fury Road No Yes No
Spotlight No No No
Network Yes No No
The Wages of Fear No No No
Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid Yes No No
Deadpool No No No
The 400 Blows No No No
Shutter Island No No No
Stand By Me No Yes No
In the Name of the Father No Yes No
Persona No No No
12 Years a Slave No No No
The Grand Budapest Hotel Yes No No
Amores Perros No No No
The Princess Bride No No No
Million Dollar Baby No Yes No
Ben-Hur No No No
Wild Tales No No Yes
Touch of Evil Yes No No
Hachi: A Dog’s Tale No No No
Annie Hall Yes No No
The Grapes of Wrath No Yes No
Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind No No No
Jurassic Park No Yes No
Stalker No No No
The Revenant No No No
Gandhi No No No
Diabolique No No No
The Bourne Ultimatum No No No
Before Sunrise No Yes No
Donnie Darko No No Yes
The Truman Show No Yes No
No No No
Memories of Murder No No No
Rocky No Yes No
The Wizard of Oz No No Yes
The Terminator No Yes No
Monsters Inc. No No No
The Best Years of Our Lives No No No
Harry Potter & the Deathly Hallows: Part 2 No Yes No
Twelve Monkeys No No No
Kind Hearts and Coronets No No Yes
Groundhog Day No Yes No
Sin City Yes No No
Strangers on a Train No Yes No
Infernal Affairs No No No
Jaws No No No
La Haine No No Yes
The Battle of Algiers No No No
Barry Lyndon No No No
Prisoners No No No
Dog Day Afternoon No No No
The Martian No No No
Ip Man Yes No No
The Imitation Game No No No
Catch Me If You Can No No No
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl No Yes No
Fanny and Alexander No No No
The Avengers Yes No No
Guardians of the Galaxy No Yes No
The Help Yes No No
A Fistful of Dollars No Yes No
The King’s Speech Yes No No
Castle in the Sky No No No
Roman Holiday No Yes No
High Noon No Yes No
Throne of Blood No No No
Beauty and the Beast No No No
In the Mood for Love No No No
Gangs of Wasseypur No No No
Lagaan: Once Upon a Time in India No No No
La Dolce Vita No No No

Note: Research conducted w/c 6 June 2016 on Netflix, Amazon Video & Now TV in the UK.

The Shopomo editorial team writes our buying guides and reviews based on first-hand knowledge of the products featured and the marketplace they operate in. Shopomo makes a small commission on links to a retailer if a purchase is made but the final decision to feature a product, and how highly it is rated, is purely an editorial one.